Skip to main content


Spent a small fortune buying smart light bulbs & got an Alexa for Xmas to link them all up so they are voice controlled. Over a month or more I've had to try to convince my wife how good it was. After another couple of months, I have realised it's an absolute pain in the arse.
in reply to Fesshole 🧻

you are doing good work here making smart home refusniks happy. So I think it was worth it.
in reply to Fesshole 🧻

I never understood the idea of a smart light bulb. I went ahead and bought smart wall switches instead. Why would I want to give up the ability to control the light from the wall?

There are two use cases that make sense to me. One is being able to turn off all the lights in the basement without going there. The other is setting timers on the outdoor lights so they turn on at sunset and off at sunrise. But not much more beyond that.

in reply to Fesshole 🧻

being in a forum of people constantly trying to configure and make their smart home shit communicate with each other and work correctly has 100% convinced me that regular old light switches are great.
in reply to Fesshole 🧻

this works until it doesn’t. Ours broke and for months the only way I could turn the lights on or off was to text my partner.
Unknown parent

MarkS

I've never seen a smart bulb that was controllable from a wall switch. Normally, the bulb has to be powered continuously.

In one case, I replaced a wall switch with a Smart switch, then wrote a back end program to turn on and off a smart ceiling light. But it was a hack. It's sort of kind of works. But I wouldn't recommend it.

This entry was edited (7 months ago)
in reply to MarkS

@MarkS My wall switches are all just Zigbee buttons which tell the smart bulb to turn on
in reply to Alexandra Lanes

@ajlanes

Are the light bulbs also zigbee? Or are you just using normal bulbs with zigbee wall switches.

in reply to Alexandra Lanes

@ajlanes

I had too much installed lighting to replace it all. So smart wall switches were the way to go for me.

I also went for Wi-Fi based switches, so I wouldn't have yet another network in my house. It works very so-so. I went with a cheap chinese brand. Occasionally they forget the network and I have to reprogram them. But it mostly works.

in reply to MarkS

@ajlanes

I'm also guessing the bulbs had to be wired with continuous power. Which makes sense in a renovation or new construction, but doesn't work so well in a retrofit, like my situation.

in reply to MarkS

@MarkS If you’re replacing the switch with a smart button you fixed-wire the light there. I retrofitted this in my 1940s semi.
in reply to MarkS

@MarkS Last thing I wanted is my light switches having anything to do with my WiFi or house network!
Unknown parent

@Sarah Brown @MarkS I’m afraid you won’t because the hill fell off the network.
⇧